2011 season

BCS era

Latest update: 2026-10-18 5:01 am ET  |  Week 15 status: COMPLETE

2011 Harbin Rankings

Power 4 conferences

Other FBS conferences

Independents

2011 season summary

Harbin's top two are LSU and Oklahoma St; the title game was LSU vs Alabama, so Harbin got 1 of 2 right; across the whole BCS lineup (title game and four bowls), run by that year's rules, Harbin matches 10 of 10 teams.

Among games between teams the BCS standings ranked, Harbin put the loser above the winner in 11 of 41 (the BCS standings: 10), and picked 6 of 9 postseason games (the BCS standings: 5), level with the BCS standings overall.

It flags no team that looks out of place.

Ineligible for the postseason, so ranked but left out of Harbin's field: USC (#5).

MeasureHarbinBCS standings (2011-12-06)
Results contradicted (fewer is better)11 of 41 (27%)10 of 41 (24%)
Postseason picks right6 of 9 (67%)5 of 9 (56%)
Playoff field matched10 of 10 (100%)n/a

Field changes

Title game: Harbin LSU vs Oklahoma St; real LSU vs Alabama.

Teams Harbin would add to, or drop from, the real field (the title game and the four BCS bowls).

Title game

Teams Harbin would put into, or take out of, the national-title game (those not already listed above).

Harbin puts in the title game

TeamHarbinBCS standingsWhy
Oklahoma St#2#3
  • Against Alabama (the team it displaces), Oklahoma St beat 3 teams with 9+ wins (Kansas St 10-2, Baylor 9-3 and Oklahoma 9-3), so its beaten opponents earned 419.5 Level 1 points in all (356.0 for Alabama's), a Level 2 term of 29.1 to 24.7; Alabama beat 4 teams with losing records (Ole Miss 2-10, Kent State 5-7, North Texas 5-7 and Tennessee 5-7) and FCS GA Southern, which add little to Level 2. This accounts for 4.41 of the 4.70-point rating gap (94%).
  • Oklahoma St beat 3 Harbin top-25 teams (Oklahoma #8, Kansas St #10 and Baylor #16) and 3 more in the top 50 (Texas #32, Tulsa #44 and Missouri #47); Alabama, the team it displaces, has 2 top-25 wins and 1 more in the top 50.

Harbin takes out of the title game

TeamHarbinBCS standingsWhy
Alabama#3#2
  • Against Oklahoma St (the team that takes its place), Alabama's beaten opponents earned 356.0 Level 1 points in all (419.5 for Oklahoma St's), a Level 2 term of 24.7 to 29.1. Alabama beat 4 teams with losing records (Ole Miss 2-10, Kent State 5-7, North Texas 5-7 and Tennessee 5-7) and FCS GA Southern, which add little to Level 2; Oklahoma St beat 3 teams with 9+ wins (Kansas St 10-2, Baylor 9-3 and Oklahoma 9-3). This accounts for 4.41 of the 4.70-point rating gap (94%).

Not eligible for the postseason

These teams rank in Harbin's top 25 but could not play in the postseason. They stay in the rankings, shaded pink, and are skipped for every field and cut line.

TeamHarbinW-LWhy
USC#510-2NCAA sanctions: Second year of the two-year NCAA bowl ban in the Reggie Bush case (10-2).

Biggest disagreements

TeamHarbinBCS standingsW-LWhy
Auburn#43#257-5
  • Against Notre Dame (Harbin #25, the spot the BCS standings gives Auburn), Auburn's beaten opponents earned 184.5 Level 1 points in all (243.0 for Notre Dame's), a Level 2 term of 12.6 to 16.8. Auburn beat 2 teams with losing records (FAU 1-11 and Ole Miss 2-10) and FCS Samford, which add little to Level 2; Notre Dame beat 1 team with 9+ wins (Michigan St 10-3). This accounts for 4.02 of the 4.95-point rating gap (81%).
Arkansas#22#610-2
  • Against Michigan (Harbin #6, the spot the BCS standings gives Arkansas), Arkansas's beaten opponents earned 258.5 Level 1 points in all (355.5 for Michigan's), a Level 2 term of 18.0 to 24.5. Arkansas beat 4 teams with losing records (New Mexico 1-11, Ole Miss 2-10, Troy 3-9 and Tennessee 5-7) and FCS Missouri St, which add little to Level 2; Michigan beat 1 team with 9+ wins (Nebraska 9-3). This accounts for 6.71 of the 6.73-point rating gap (100%).
Oregon#13#511-2
  • Against USC (Harbin #5, the spot the BCS standings gives Oregon), The teams Oregon played had 158 games on their schedules in all, against 147 for USC's, and Level 2 is divided by that total, so each team Oregon beat adds less. This accounts for 1.66 of the 2.82-point rating gap (59%).
  • Oregon's beaten opponents earned 344.5 Level 1 points in all (357.5 for USC's), a Level 2 term of 21.8 to 24.3. Oregon beat 5 teams with losing records (Colorado 3-10, Oregon St 3-9, Arizona 4-8, Washington St 4-8 and 1 more) and FCS Missouri St, which add little to Level 2; USC beat 1 team with 9+ wins (Oregon 11-2). This accounts for 0.85 of the 2.82-point rating gap (30%).
Georgia#24#1610-3
  • Against Baylor (Harbin #16, the spot the BCS standings gives Georgia), Georgia lost the SEC title game to LSU (13-0): it was its 13th game and earned 0 points, so its Level 1 average fell from 5.00 to 4.62 and LSU's 13 games went into its divisor with nothing earned; without that game Georgia would rate 24.76 instead of 22.74. This accounts for 2.02 of the 2.16-point rating gap (94%).
  • Georgia's beaten opponents earned 284.5 Level 1 points in all (294.0 for Baylor's), a Level 2 term of 19.8 to 20.6. Georgia beat 4 teams with losing records (Ole Miss 2-10, New Mexico St 4-9, Kentucky 5-7 and Tennessee 5-7) and FCS Coastal, which add little to Level 2; Baylor beat 2 teams with 9+ wins (TCU 10-2 and Oklahoma 9-3). This accounts for 0.66 of the 2.16-point rating gap (31%).
Texas#32#247-5
  • Against Georgia (Harbin #24, the spot the BCS standings gives Texas), Texas's beaten opponents earned 210.5 Level 1 points in all (284.5 for Georgia's), a Level 2 term of 14.5 to 19.8. Texas beat 4 teams with losing records (Kansas 2-10, Rice 4-8, Texas Tech 5-7 and UCLA 6-7), which add little to Level 2; Georgia beat no team with 9+ wins. This accounts for 5.12 points, more than the whole 4.68-point rating gap; other factors pull the other way.
  • Texas lost 5 of its 12 games (Oklahoma 9-3, Oklahoma St 11-1, Missouri 7-5, Kansas St 10-2 and 1 more), and every loss is a game worth 0 points in the Level 1 average: 7 of its 12 games earn points, against 10 of 12 for Georgia (lost to Boise St 11-1 and South Carolina 10-2). This accounts for 1.51 of the 4.68-point rating gap (32%).
Michigan#6#1310-2
  • Against Oregon (Harbin #13, the spot the BCS standings gives Michigan), The teams Oregon played had 158 games on their schedules in all, against 145 for Michigan's, and Level 2 is divided by that total, so each team Oregon beat adds less. This accounts for 1.99 of the 2.64-point rating gap (75%).
  • Michigan beat 1 team with 9+ wins (Nebraska 9-3), so its beaten opponents earned 355.5 Level 1 points in all (344.5 for Oregon's), a Level 2 term of 24.5 to 21.8; Oregon beat 5 teams with losing records (Colorado 3-10, Oregon St 3-9, Arizona 4-8, Washington St 4-8 and 1 more) and FCS Missouri St, which add little to Level 2. This accounts for 0.73 of the 2.64-point rating gap (28%).
  • Michigan beat 2 Harbin top-25 teams (Nebraska #15 and Notre Dame #25) and 1 more in the top 50 (Illinois #50).
Oklahoma#8#149-3
  • Against Wisconsin (Harbin #14, the spot the BCS standings gives Oklahoma), The teams Wisconsin played had 158 games on their schedules in all, against 144 for Oklahoma's, and Level 2 is divided by that total, so each team Wisconsin beat adds less. This accounts for 2.10 points, more than the whole 1.72-point rating gap; other factors pull the other way.
  • Oklahoma beat 1 Harbin top-25 team (Kansas St #10) and 5 more in the top 50 (Texas #32, Iowa State #37, Tulsa #44, Florida St #45 and Missouri #47).
  • Oklahoma's loss to 5-7 Texas Tech counts no more in Harbin than a loss to a top-10 team; it is #14 in the BCS standings.
Clemson#9#1510-3
  • Against Nebraska (Harbin #15, the spot the BCS standings gives Clemson), Clemson beat 1 team with 9+ wins (Virginia Tech 11-2), so its beaten opponents earned 358.5 Level 1 points in all (314.5 for Nebraska's), a Level 2 term of 22.8 to 21.5; Nebraska beat 2 teams with losing records (Minnesota 3-9 and Fresno St 4-9) and FCS Chattanooga, which add little to Level 2. This accounts for 2.91 points, more than the whole 1.58-point rating gap; other factors pull the other way.
  • Clemson beat 2 Harbin top-25 teams (Virginia Tech #7 and Virginia Tech #7) and 3 more in the top 50 (North Carolina #28, Auburn #43 and Florida St #45).
  • Clemson's Level 2 term (22.8) ranks #9 in FBS: Harbin rewards beating teams that won a lot.

Compared with BCS standings of 2011-12-06. Written 2026-10-17 from games through 2011-12-06.